The other day an older relative of mine came up to me and told me that he had an idea for a book.
I smiled politely, listened to the idea, and tried to give him the impression that I appreciated the idea and would certainly keep it in mind for the future.
I’ve already forgotten the idea.
I’m sure that it happens in all of the arts, people coming up and telling you what you should do next, but I honestly think that it’s worse for the storytellers. Whether you write books, plays, movies, commercials… whatever it is that you do, everybody, an I mean everybody, has at least one idea for that medium that they think is pure gold.
Here’s the thing people: your idea might very well be brilliant! It might be the greatest story idea that anybody has ever come up with in the history of mankind. It doesn’t matter. I don’t want to write your story for you. In a few select cases, for very close friends or people in the industry, I might be willing to try writing a story with you, but by god, I’m not going to make that journey on my own.
Because the idea is the easy part!
Yes, you heard me right, the idea is the easy part. I know you’re skeptical. You’ve read books based on stupid ideas, you’ve watched movies where the plot is so thin it would fall apart if you blew your nose on it. There are plenty of terrible ideas that somehow come into the light of day. Given.
But it’s still the easiest part of the process.
I’ve got plenty of ideas. I could spend the rest of my life writing the books that are currently sitting in my mental queue. Okay, maybe not the rest of my life, but well over a decade, trust me on this.
The hard part of telling a story isn’t the idea, it’s bringing the idea to life. The reason writers go to conferences and read books and join critique groups and hire editors has nothing to do with fixing our ideas or making them better: It’s all about getting what’s in our head onto the page in such a way that somebody else can appreciate it!
Don’t get me wrong, I’m happy that my relative knows that I’m a writer and wants to talk to me about the things that I’m interested in. I’m happy that when he thinks about books and stories he thinks about me and wants to be included in that part of my life.
But I do rather wish that every time we talked he wasn’t trying to put a new project on my plate.